Make A Payment Grapeville Agency offers easy convenient payment methods to meet your individual needs; Click on the insurance provider below to make a payment or call the phone number to speak to the payment center. 1-800-458-0811 Option 9 1-800-255-7828 1-877-629-8003 1-800-956-3728 1-800-333-7234 1-877-468-3466 1-800-244-1545 1-877-248-0555 1-315-736-8211 1-800-776-4737 1-800-842-5075 1-860-547-5000 1-800-532-4221